vinesh-phogat-a-champion-despite-cas-dismissal

The decision of the Court of Arbitration for Sport (CAS) to dismiss wrestler Vinesh Phogat's appeal against her disqualification from the Olympic games was met with disappointment by the Indian sports community. However, they stressed that she will continue to be regarded as a champion by them.

 

On Wednesday, the ad-hoc division of the CAS turned down Vinesh's appeal against her disqualification from the 50kg final at the Paris Olympics due to being 100gm overweight. This ruling extinguished any chances of her earning a delayed silver medal.

 

"It's disappointing but we can't do anything about that," hockey legend PR Sreejesh, who retired after inspiring the Indian team to a second consecutive Olympic bronze medal in the Paris Games, told PTI Videos.

 

Tokyo Olympics bronze medallist Bajrang Punia said a medal had been snatched away from Vinesh.

 

"I believe your medal was snatched away in this darkness. You are shining like a diamond in the whole world today," Punia, who led a long sit-in protest along with Vinesh and Sakshi Malik accusing former WFI chief Brij Bhushan Sharan Singh of sexually harassing women grapplers, posted on 'X'.

 

"World champion pride of Hindustan, Rustam-e-Hind Vinesh Phogat, you are the Kohinoor of the country. It's Vinesh Phogat all over the world. Those who want medals, can buy them for Rs 15 each," he wrote with a picture of Vinesh wearing several medals.

 

Vinesh, aged 29, was eliminated from the women's 50kg freestyle final last week in the morning.

 

Vinesh's appeal requested to be awarded a joint silver medal with Cuban wrestler Yusneylis Guzman Lopez, who she defeated in the semifinals but advanced to the final after Vinesh's disqualification.

 

The gold medal was won by American wrestler Sarah Ann Hildebrandt.

 

The decision on Vinesh's appeal was delayed three times. Even though the deadline was extended until August 16 to announce the verdict, the decision against the renowned wrestler was finally made on Wednesday evening in the form of a brief one-line statement.

 

"It is a sad news but what can we say. A sportsperson works extremely hard and if something like this happens with anyone, it hurts. For us, Vinesh is a star, will always be," said hockey player Jarmanpreet Singh.

 

His team-mate Amit Rohidas said "the whole of India is with her".

 

"She should held her head high. She is a champion for us and the country." National wrestling coach Virendra Dahiya termed the CAS decision "unfortunate".

 

"It is very unfortunate and a jolt for us. We were very hopeful that the decision would be in our favour. But it is unfortunate for Indian wrestling and the country," he said.

 

Indian Olympic Association President PT Usha had also expressed "shock and disappointment" at the turn of events.

 

The body also lashed out at the "inhumane regulations" of the United World Wrestling (UWW) that fail to consider the "physiological and psychological stresses faced by athletes".

 

The IOA had roped in senior counsels Harish Salve and Vidushpat Singhania to help Vinesh in her case.

 

"The decision of the CAS was really disappointing. We were very hopeful, Vinesh worked hard the most. After the timeline was extended, we thought the arbitrator Madam was having a thought and that decision could be in our favour. But it was dismissed with a one line statement," Singhania said.

 

"We have to wait for the detailed order, we have to see what is written there and accordingly will take a decision regarding future course of action." Asked what was the argument on the part of Vinesh, he said, "The UWW (wrestling world governing body) had argued that rules are rules and if it (weight category) is 50kg, you are allowed only 50kg and nothing above that.

 

"Our plea was on a different line that you have to see the human right aspect, there is ambiguity in the rules, no clarity on the rules. But it seems our plea has been rejected and why it was rejected will be known only when the detailed order comes." Vinesh is expected to return home on Saturday.